"I PLAY ROCKY" - REVIEW
We live in an interesting era of moviegoing. Rather, we live in an age of interesting moviegoing nostalgia.
We celebrate the birthdays of movies. Movies have become culturally significant time markers. As movies have been known to trend toward existing IP, we have now entered a new phase, similar to when movies were adapted into Broadway musicals and then re-adapted into movies: now we have filmed entertainment which chronicles the origin stories of our favorite pieces of iconic filmed entertainment. While not a movie, the Paramount+ series THE OFFER chronicles the origins of the movie THE GODFATHER in a music biopic-y way.
One read is that Hollywood is so bereft of original ideas (or more accurately, increasingly risk-averse when it comes to banking on original ideas) that its machinery is content with this ouroboros cash-grab mentality that bankrolls and releases something like I PLAY ROCKY.
And yet, we will always value the underdog.
So another read, and in my opinion, a better read, is to just simply enjoy the impossible miracle of creating something so intense and emotionally satisfying and entertaining from something that we already know extremely well; from a classic movie which, incidentally, turned 50 this year.
If it is buttery popcorn you want, director Peter Farrelly and company serve up a gigantic tub, and if you’re willing to check your cynicism at the door, you will happily devour every kernel of I PLAY ROCKY, which I found to be an impossibly miraculous film. I was gobsmacked.
Before I get into it, I must divulge that I am and have always been a huge fan of Peter Farrelly, who is perhaps one of the first directors to make an imprint on me when I started to care about movies. His films, especially the earlier ones he made with his brother Bobby—the best of which include their masterpiece DUMB AND DUMBER (1994), and then KINGPIN (1996), THERE’S SOMETHING ABOUT MARY (1998), SHALLOW HAL (2001) and STUCK ON YOU (2003)—were unfussy, unpretentious laugh machines with a sweet, soft center, a lot of heart, and a knowingness about underdogs. There’s a great story from the making of DUMB AND DUMBER in which the studio asked “who’s directing this movie?” and Peter confidently proclaimed “I am.” That was the end of the discussion. Shortly before filming commenced on DUMBER, Peter called up the Zucker Brothers (AIRPLANE!, TOP SECRET) for tips, since he had never directed anything before, not even a short film. The Zuckers told him to not worry about the cameras, that the DP will take care of that stuff, to which Peter replied, “what’s a DP?!” A great case of fake-it-until-you-make-it.
After their Kings-of-Comedy run throughout the 1990s and early 2000s, and after Bobby experienced a family tragedy, Peter struck out on his own in a new, less overtly comic direction with 2018’s now-controversial race-relation dramedy GREEN BOOK (which I actually loved at the time, while also agreeing that its Best Picture win in the same year as Alfonso Cuaron’s ROMA and Spike Lee’s BLACKkKLANSMAN was dubious at best). Peter followed that with three direct-to-streaming films: Apple TV+’s fair-to-middlin’ Vietnam War buddy comedy THE GREATEST BEER RUN EVER starring Zac Efron; Prime Video’s riotous RICKY STANICKY starring Efron and a hilarious John Cena; and this year’s deeply questionable Prime Video release BALLS UP with Mark Wahlberg and Paul Walter Hauser (which has a hilarious karaoke scene set to “Somebody That I Used To Know,” and little else to recommend it).
Coming into I PLAY ROCKY, I had doubts, given the inconsistency, the dubiousness of the GREEN BOOK Oscars, and given that it was a movie about the making of a movie that everybody with a pulse loves. Here, Farrelly marries his sensibilities and makes I PLAY ROCKY from the bones of ROCKY: a big-hearted, sincere, uncynical crowdpleaser.
I PLAY ROCKY follows the true underdog story of an up-and-coming younger actor and screenwriter named Sylvester (Anthony Ippolito doing an uncanny Stallone, following his uncanny Pacino in THE OFFER). Trying to book acting gigs in New York City as “Mike Stallone,” Sylvester is a young man of sharp intellect and insights despite his meathead presence, his speech impediment, and his working-class, “from a different generation” tough-love pop Frank (Matt Dillon, reuniting with Farrelly for the first time since his movie-stealing turn in THERE’S SOMETHING ABOUT MARY). Sylvester meets a photographer Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb, SOUL SURFER), and they quickly fall for each other while working at a movie theater, where Sylvester shares some informed opinions on movies, and to which Sasha inspires him to “write your own movie! And give yourself the best part!”
Cut to Sly and Sasha trying to rub two nickels together out in Hollywood while parking cars on the side; with Sly’s stack of screenplays (which Sasha types from his longhand pages) almost as high as their past due bills. One night in a bar, Sly witnesses a TV boxing match: Muhammad Ali against Chuck Wepner, a boxer who had no chance at dethroning the champ but who himself would not go down, who had no quit in him. In a flurry of inspiration, Sly races back to his legal pad and in three days writes ROCKY.
It gets better. His writing catches the eye of producers Irwin Winkler (PJ Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell), who have already started casting it aloud, to watch Stallone delivers the title line, standing his ground.
From there we get wrapped up in the mechanics of Hollywood dealmaking with the amusing back-and-forth between Winkler/Chartoff and studio head composite character Sandy Maddox (played with blustery gusto by the great Tracy Letts); we get actors who’ve never boxed before, like Stallone himself and like auditioning actor Carl Weathers (Stephan James, IF BEALE STREET COULD TALK); we get cranky, cocky director John G. Avildsen (a hilarious Jay Duplass, DYING FOR SEX) who shoots fast and has strong opinions; we get doctors who tell Sly to stay off his feet; we have studio clauses that underfund the movie and threaten to take everything away if they even fall one day behind. And then, well… the rest is history.
Is it cosplay? Sure. Is it emotionally involving cosplay? You bet. Would you rather watch ROCKY? 100%. Would you favor another viewing of the grossout classics Peter made with his brother Bobby? That depends on you. Should it be up for Oscars in the same way that the original was? I wouldn’t go that far, but also who cares? Will you enjoy this? Unless you are made of stone yourself. Look: I found this movie to be phenomenal and delightful. It’s a great film about underdogs, and a great film about filmmaking, and a genuine crowd pleaser.
I cannot wait for people to see this.
Also, stay all the way to the end of the credits!
I PLAY ROCKY is in theaters everywhere.
#moviefriend
#iplayrocky
#AmazonMGMStudios
@mncritics
Zach is a proud member of the Minnesota Film Critics Association (MNFCA). For more info about Zach, the organization, or to read other great reviews from other great Minnesota-based film critics, click here: www.mnfca.com